Cerrar Menú Blogs
Las opiniones de los blogueros son de su estricta responsabilidad y no representan la opinión de este portal.
Profile image

Ingresa o regístrate acá para seguir este blog.

Seguir este blog

‘From war to peace: lessons from Ireland for Colombia.’
Thus ran the title of a talk Northern Ireland’s Deputy First Minister, Martin McGuinness, gave in Bogotá this week.

Looking down over a more peaceful Belfast.

Belfast City: Not exactly a sea of tranquillity but much better than it was. Can Colombia learn from the Irish example?

The former IRA man, now very much in favour of the ballot box over the gun, is certainly well qualified to lecture on the subject.* And while Northern Ireland’s peace hits occasional stumbling blocks (it is a continuous process after all), there can be no disputing the fact that things are far brighter there these days since the protagonists decided to seriously ‘give peace a chance’. The odd verbal political fight, albeit frustrating at times, is much easier to take than bombing campaigns and tit-for-tat murders.

Given its relative success, it’s no surprise that the Irish case is held up as an example for other present-day conflicts to follow.

So coming back to the title of McGuinness’ talk, what are the lessons, if any, that Colombia can learn from the Northern Irish peace process?

For one, the fact that a process is actually in place and the parties to the conflict are talking must be highlighted as a good thing. (For the record, those at the peace negotiations are namely the Farc guerillas on the one hand and the government on the other, which not only stands for legitimate state security [and in theory the citizens] but also the paramilitaries whose actions were often allowed go unchecked by the powers that be.)

To this end, President Juan Manuel Santos and his administration deserve credit. You could be forgiven for thinking that there was no big risk in opening up talks, a natural step to take after decades of practically zero-sum warfare. Not here in Colombia, though. You’ll find that many who voted for Santos did so in the belief that he would follow the hard-line taken by his predecessor Álvaro Uribe: That effectively being ‘exterminate rather than communicate’.

For sure Colombians have reasons to be sceptical when it comes to peace talks with the Farc. There have been empty promises and false dawns before. Throw in the fact that these latest discussions are taking place without a ceasefire in operation and you can see why some question the legitimacy of the whole process. But generally, sitting down and talking with the ‘evil’ others is more productive over time than continuing with what amounts to an unwinnable war.

Also, in most conflicts there comes a moment when the struggle loses its appeal, its strength, and conditions become ripe for settlement. In the Northern Ireland case, the blueprint for peace was laid down as early as 1973 with the Sunningdale Agreement. However, for a large number on both sides of the divide, the timing wasn’t seen as right then; the warpath still seemed more favourable than the political one. It took another 25 years and plenty more coffins in the ground before the foundations of the current peace were agreed on – pretty much mirroring a lot of what was signalled in 1973. As the moderate Irish nationalist politician Seamus Mallon famously stated at the signing of the Good Friday (Belfast) Agreement in 1998, it was ‘Sunningdale for slow learners’.

For Colombia, the question must therefore be asked, are the conditions now ripe for a lasting settlement to be reached? Looking at it from a Farc point of view, where is the incentive for it to lay down its arms? Going ‘legit’ and becoming a political force could actually be akin to turning the gun on itself.

In this regard, the guerillas can point to the not-too-distant past and their flirtation with the democratic process via the Unión Patriótica (UP, Patriotic Union – a party which subsequently distanced itself from the rebels) in the 1980s. To say that this party was systematically annihilated by paramilitaries is an understatement. Add in the fact that the democratic right still rules at election time in this country and a politicised Farc, at this juncture in Colombia’s political story anyway, is unlikely to have much success at the polls.

McGuinness -- Bogotá

Here to help: McGuinness speaking about the Colombian peace talks. (Picture credit: Steven James Grattan/Amy Farrell.)

Then, of course, you have the extremely lucrative global drugs business. It would be foolish not to think that for some guerillas, along with other underworld players, this is more important to ‘stay in the game’ for compared to any perceived revolutionary ideals.

McGuinness spoke of the international element to Northern Ireland’s peace process – the US assistance and the Independent International Commission on Decommissioning headed up by General John de Chastelain to name just two. Similarly, but to a far greater extent, any peace deal in Colombia will surely require a global strategy shift on another seemingly unwinnable war – the one being waged on drugs.**

This is something President Santos has previously highlighted. The key, of course, is finding an effective solution. On the ground here, for what it’s worth, McGuinness stressed what he felt was a genuine enthusiasm from those negotiating to come up with a meaningful deal.

Yet the cash cow of cocaine and other such drugs might literally blow up in their faces. For while the prospect of peace for Northern Ireland brought with it the chance of an economic upturn and a political high life for many of the players involved, McGuinness included, the opposite could well be the case for some of Colombia’s principal players in this conflict resolution quest.

As noted earlier, though, it’s better to be talking than burying heads in the sand.

However, if a peace deal is to be Santos’ legacy, he might just need at least another four years in office to realise that.
*For a brief background on Martin McGuinness, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_McGuinness.

**See also Colombia’s path to peace?, written when news of these latest peace talks was made public.

Facebook: Wrong Way Corrigan – The Blog.

(Visited 339 times, 1 visits today)
Profile image

La vida en Colombia desde la perspectiva de un periodista y locutor irlandés, quien ha vivido en el país desde 2011. El blog explora temas sociales y culturales, interacción con los nativos, viajes, actualidades y mucho más. Escucha su podcast acá: https://anchor.fm/brendan-corrigan.

Más posts de este Blog

Ver más

Lo más leído en Blogs


Si el año pasado fue importante para las relaciones entre Colombia(...)


Colombia históricamente ha sido un país importador de textiles, de productos(...)


Tomó cinco piedras del río y las guardó en su mochila.(...)

0 Comentarios
Ingresa aquí para que puedas comentar este post
Reglamento de comentarios

ETCE no se responsabiliza por el uso y tratamiento que los usuarios le den a la información publicada en este espacio de recomendaciones, pero aclara que busca ser la sombrilla de un espacio donde el equilibrio y la tolerancia sean el eje. En ese camino, disponemos de total libertad para eliminar los contenidos que:

  1. Promuevan mensajes tipo spam.
  2. El odio ante una persona o comunidad por su condición social, racial, sexual, religiosa o de situación de discapacidad.
  3. Muestren o impulsen comportamientos o lenguajes sexualmente explícitos, violentos o dañinos.
  4. Vulneren o atenten contra los derechos de los menores de edad.

Además, tenga en cuenta que:

  • - El usuario registrado solo podrá hacer un voto y veto por comentario.
¿Encontraste un error?

Para EL TIEMPO las observaciones sobre su contenido son importantes. Permítenos conocerlas para, si es el caso, tomar los correctivos necesarios, o darle trámite ante las instancias pertinentes dentro de EL TIEMPO Casa Editorial.

Debes escribir el comentario
¡Gracias! Tu comentario ha sido guardado
Tu calificación ha sido registrada
Tu participación ya fue registrada
Haz tu reporte
Debes escribir tu reporte
Tu reporte ha sido enviado con éxito
Debes ser usuario registrado para poder reportar este comentario. Cerrar